Generally speaking MAC addresses will not cross routers. But there must be a way to get the MAC address of a remote system. I've seen it done with a program called Network View. So why can I not do this on Linux?
We need to inventory some information on all our computers: Ip Address, Mac Address, building, room, id number, hostname etc. I figured on putting up a form but have it pull the system's ip address and mac address automatically so it can be easily dropped into a database. It works fine locally, but if we go to another building, I cannot get the MAC address as we are now on a seperate network.
Acquiring MAC Address of Remote System
Moderators: snarkout, Patrick, dann
Re: Acquiring MAC Address of Remote System
I don't have my TCP/IP book handy, but I'm pretty sure the MAC is not in the IP packet. The mapping happens at the LAN level. The router knows which IP belongs to which MAC. You may have to get the router to give you that info.dann wrote:Generally speaking MAC addresses will not cross routers. But there must be a way to get the MAC address of a remote system. I've seen it done with a program called Network View. So why can I not do this on Linux?
HOw to do that is an exercise left to the student.
Can you run something on a machine on the remote network?
Running something on the target machine begins to extend beyond the simplicity I wanted to achieve here. The person will be sitting down in front of the remote system and going to a web page. They could just run ipconfig /all and paste the MAC address into a form field, but I was hoping this would be able to be culled automatically.
I'm wondering how netview does it. There has been no special configuration on our end for this app to work. We pointed it to a remote netware server and it pulled up the proper MAC address.
I'm wondering how netview does it. There has been no special configuration on our end for this app to work. We pointed it to a remote netware server and it pulled up the proper MAC address.
-
StoneChucker
- Posts: 16
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 9:57 pm
- Location: Brantford, Ontario
- Contact:
How about having the end user execute a batch file, containing:
where X: is a shared network location (could be mapped within the batch file if not already present), and %COMPUTERNAME% is a standard system variable of the "computername".
I think that will get you what you want, on a Windows PC anyways (as you mentioned ipconfig).
Hope this helps,
StoneChucker
Code: Select all
ipconfig /all X:\%COMPUTERNAME%.txtI think that will get you what you want, on a Windows PC anyways (as you mentioned ipconfig).
Hope this helps,
StoneChucker
Ok, well I work a *lot* on writing code in this space and here's the problem. Network View uses WMI to gather this information. So on Windows machines there is a WMI namespace called Win32_NetworkAdapterConfiguration.
The problem is that there is no implementation on *nix which allows querying of WMI, well natively on Linux anyway.
But Dann, what exactly is the problem? Is it just that you can't do this from Linux or what? My development is mainly focused solving problems like this. If I could gather WMI information from Linux my entire development system would be totally different!
Unfortunately, writing a program to solve this problem for Windows is a no-brainer but on Linux its very different (until someone decides to implement the DCOM interfaces to make it possible).
The problem is that there is no implementation on *nix which allows querying of WMI, well natively on Linux anyway.
But Dann, what exactly is the problem? Is it just that you can't do this from Linux or what? My development is mainly focused solving problems like this. If I could gather WMI information from Linux my entire development system would be totally different!
Unfortunately, writing a program to solve this problem for Windows is a no-brainer but on Linux its very different (until someone decides to implement the DCOM interfaces to make it possible).